New Mexican & Italian duo from the Duggan family of legendary Original Joe’s packs them in

Elena’s Mexican chile con queso. Photo by Virginia Miller.

As many in San Francisco struggle with half-empty restaurants and continued post-pandemic fallout of higher costs, staffing issues and the BS, scapegoat “doom loop,” a local restaurant group have recently opened two restaurants packed at an almost rabid level since opening. Are these cutting-edge boundary-pushers? No. They’re traditional American-Mexican and Italian formulas.Third-generation owners/siblings John and Elena Duggan oversee SF’s legendary Original Joe’s restaurants since grandfather Tony Rodin opened the Tenderloin original in 1937, now in North Beach. In 2016, they took over 1956 Daly City icon, Original Joe’s Westlake, then opened the first Little Original Joe’s in West Portal in 2020, a COVID-friendly market and takeout spot.

In February 2024, they debuted Elena’s in chill West Portal where Elena and John grew up. A different direction than all four Joe’s, Elena’s is a Mexican-American restaurant, both modern and refreshingly old school, honoring Elena’s daughters’ Mexican heritage. On May 30, 2024, they opened a second Little Original Joe’s (LOJ’s) in an art deco Marina building, but it’s not a market, nor is little. LOJ’s Marina is a full restaurant. Both are tough tables to snag.

Little Original Joe’s Marina. Photo by Virginia Miller.

What’s the “secret sauce” making the Duggan’s restaurants mobbed and beloved in different neighborhoods? Surely there are multiple “sauces” factoring in their ongoing success, starting with the quality of their team. General managers like Christian Canpos, who oversees Westlake but was at the new Marina LOJ’s in opening weeks, exemplify gracious hospitality, walking around checking in with guests, spreading welcome. Attentive staff, timely food and drinks, even Elena herself walking the floor when I dined at LOJ’s, confirm this is a hands-on team focused on hospitality first.

Getting that cornerstone of the industry right since the days of their grandfather and parents, the Duggan’s winning formula also includes design and heaping portions of crowd-pleasing food. Sounds simple, right? They have it dialed in. Elena’s and LOJ’s Marina are open all day, making tough-to-snag seats more doable.

Little Original Joe’s zucchini fries. Photo by Virginia Miller.

Digging first into LOJ’s, the space is bright and inviting with black-and-white checkered flooring, custom chandeliers, black leather booths and bustling bar. You’ll find the pastas and Italian-American fare of other OJ’s, also rotisserie chicken, ten pizzas in their unique style and, blissfully, a Parmigiana menu section! Unique to the Marina, zucchini fries are dream bar food. Thinly-shaved, oh-so-delicately-fried zucchini strips make a striking mountain laden in shaved Parmigiano Reggiano, dipped in lemon basil aioli. Brilliant. So is a shaved Brussels sprouts salad tossed with toasted walnuts, green onion, pecorino romano cheese and lemon vinaigrette. Both dishes are gratifying yet light and airy.

Little Original Joe’s Parmigiana. Photo by Virginia Miller.

While Joe’s has long nailed American-Italian classics like piccata, five versions of Parmigiana delights with a vegetarian mushroom Parmigiana just at this location. I go for spicy vodka Parmigiana, a lightly-breaded chicken cutlet layered with prosciutto, mozzarella and spicy vodka sauce, transporting me back to my teen Jersey years.

Little Original Joe’s California Dreamin’ pizza. Photo by Virginia Miller.

Among the pastas, casarecce spicy sausage ragu comforts, while unique-to-the-Marina is cacio e macha, a Roma-meets-Mexico play on cacio e pepe with Elena’s salsa macha over mafaldine pasta. California Dreamin’ is unexpectedly superior to any BBQ pizza ever. I usually pooh-pooh over-sauced BBQ pizzas with cheap-tasting smoked gouda. But they nail it: a nuanced blend of diced-up BBQ rotisserie chicken and sauce, mozzarella, gouda, cilantro, brightened by pickled jalapenos and red onion. Leftover slices were fab.

Little Original Joe’s Pizza Martini. Photo by Virginia Miller.

A mix of California and Italian wines parallel a fun cocktail menu with Negroni section. They nail Elena’s Espresso Martini featuring North Beach legend Graffeo’s espresso. Ditto the LOJ Pizza Martini, a savory sipper featuring Napa’s Hanson Habanero Vodka, Moletto Italian Tomato Gin, Dolin Blanc vermouth and garnish of pepperoni, stuffed black olive and pickled onion.

// Little Original Joe’s, 2301 Chestnut Street, www.littleoriginaljoes.com/loj-marina

Elena’s Mexican at night. Photo by Virginia Miller.

Now we head to Elena’s, where chef Sergio Santiago helms the kitchen. The lofty space was packed and buzzing post-opening with four hour waits and celebrities like Joe Montana. Giant booths, candle-lit ficus trees, skylights, gas-lanterned doorway and open tiled kitchen set the stage for fajitas, chile relleno and margaritas.

Elena’s tortilla soup. Photo by Virginia Miller.

Elena’s imparts almost LA vibes, reminding me of 1930s legends I grew up at like El Cholo, but with better food. Yet this is pure SF, from scene to the all-ages mix of families, 20-and-30-somethings and sweet elderly crowd. This truly reflects West Portal, a neighborhood virtually unchanged since the 1970s, like much of this half of SF, wrongly left out of discussions of the City.

Elena’s ahi tostadas with sriracha aioli, avocado, crispy leeks, black sesame. Photo by Virginia Miller.

Of course you want to start with guacamole, equites (Mexican street corn), tortilla soup, ceviche, crudo — like hamachi in black garlic ponzu, serranos and black sesame. Or chile con queso loaded with green chiles and chorizo. Basic-sounding ahi tostadas are one of the most flavorful, fun bites: mini-tostadas loaded with the tuna, Sriracha aioli, avocado, fried leeks and black sesame. But I need a group to tackle all this hearty happiness.

Elena’s chile relleno and enchilada combo platter. Photo by Virginia Miller.

Entrees and tacos platters get even heftier. Among seven different tacos, I’m happy gobernador tacos are on-menu, which I eat regularly when consulting in tequila in Jalisco, Mexico, loaded with grilled shrimp, melted cheese, salsa verde. Elena’s chile Colorado is a nurturing guajillo pork stew, as is their pork pozole. Another highlight is tamales with your choice of pork or rajas (poblano peppers), topped with crema, queso fresco and avocado salsa. As with many dishes, tamales arrive with rice and refried pinto beans. Needless to say, you won’t leave hungry.

Drinks please, from a range of tequilas, mezcals, Mexican-inspired cocktails and Margaritas. Marg standouts are a frozen Aperol Margarita and Spicy Watermelon Margarita with Chareau aloe liqueur.

Elena’s Margarita. Photo by Virginia Miller.

Desserts charm, from churros to Mexican icebox cake with lime cream, the latter my #1 given its tart, icy similarities to my beloved key lime pie. Café de olla cheesecake showcases an SF legend the Duggan family revived, Zanze’s Cheesecake, in a special Mexican-spiced version only at Elena’s.

Generosity of portions and spirit permeate LOJ’s and Elena’s, with a non-trendy, traditional approach that remains current vs. dated. This quintessential SF family continues to be a beacon in our City, drawing in the next generation of San Franciscans.

// Elena’s, 255 West Portal Avenue, www.elenasmexican.com

Elena’s frozen Aperol Margarita. Photo by Virginia Miller.
Little Original Joe’s Italian Margarita with 21 Seeds orange tequila, Mommenpop Blood Orange vermouth, Aperol, lime. Photo by Virginia Miller.